Autism research isn’t helping people live with daily reality
In the summer of 2010 as England was being knocked out of the World Cup in South Africa, something all together more hopeful was happening in London.
A group of scientists, social researchers, parents and autistic people got together to join a discussion at the Institute of Education on research into autism.
The enthusiasm for the chance to debate and discuss complicated and emotionally charged issues like the “cure” and “prevention” of autism versus notions of autistic differences and what some call “neurodiversity” was astonishing – despite, and perhaps even because of, widely opposing views.
It led colleagues and me at the Centre for Research in Autism and Education to consider the need to find out what people with autism and their families thought about the current direction of research.
In a project called A Future Made Together, funded by the charity Research Autism, we conducted the most comprehensive review of UK research into autism ever undertaken.
We consulted with more than 1,700 autistic people, their families, practitioners and researchers to understand what they thought of current autism research in the UK and where the funds towards autism research should be prioritised.
Our report acknowledged the many great strengths of autism research in the UK such as leading work in the area of cognitive psychology, stretching from the work of Sir Michael Rutter to Uta Frith. But it also noted considerable challenges in the years to come. While parents of children with autism were impressed by the amount of work that goes into autism research, they were not convinced that research had made a real difference to their lives.
One woman said:
I fill in all these questionnaires and do everything I can to help … but when it comes down to it, it’s not real life. It’s always missing the next step. It’s great you’ve done this research, you’ve listened to my views … but now do something with it.
Ignoring reality
It turns out that too many people feel that there is a huge gap between knowledge and practice. Research doesn’t seem to help their child catch the train by themselves or keep themselves safe. And it doesn’t say how to get autistic adults into jobs and keep them there.
The people we spoke to said that they don’t want to – or can’t – read about research in academic papers. They want to hear about research in accessible ways. And they want to see real changes for their child, or for the person they work with.
British academics haven’t been taking enough notice of real-life issues. Our analysis showed that the majority of UK research focuses heavily on “basic science” – neural and cognitive systems, genetics and other risk factors – rather than on research targeting the immediate circumstances in which autistic people find themselves, on services, treatments and interventions and education.
Families of people with autism valued the need for basic research to understand better its underlying causes – but they wanted a more balanced profile, weighting research with a direct impact on the daily lives of autistic people more equally with core areas of basic science than is presently the case.
My view is that we need to take research in radical new directions. We must continue to develop our world-leading skills in key areas of autism science. But significant investment is also needed in areas of autism research currently under-resourced in the UK. And in order to work out which areas need the greatest investment, we ought to be listening to people about what they want from research.
Autism researchers do not do this enough. According to our findings, autistic people, their family members, and even practitioners are rarely involved in the decision-making processes that shape research and its application. Research priorities are thus set almost exclusively by funders and academics in specialist fields.
This pattern generates concrete problems for those responsible for commissioning local autism services, people working in such services, and for autistic individuals and their families, as they attempt to make evidence-based decisions on education, health and social care.
But this is also problematic because of the feeling of exclusion that it engenders. The people that we spoke to often felt disappointed and frustrated at being “mined” for information and having little or no opportunity to learn about the resulting discoveries and what they might mean for them.
They also felt as if their expertise and knowledge – what it is like to be autistic, to care for someone who is autistic, or to work with someone who is autistic – was disregarded by researchers. This lack of reciprocity resulted in feelings of distrust and disempowerment. One autistic adult said: “Whatever we say, is that really going to influence anyone?”
The rewards of working together are manifold. In fact, it may be the only way to ensure that the research that we do really counts.
This article is co-published with the Institute of Education. A longer version of the piece appears on its blog
How robots are helping children with autism
Researchers believe robots hold the key to early diagnosis, as well as teaching social skills. What can they do that humans can’t?Software Testing Company Exclusively Hires ASD Candidates
There are roughly 500,000 adults with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) who have completed high school and/or college and offer certain attributes that make them better suited to high-level jobs like testing and debugging software than their neurotypical (i.e. not autistic) counterparts21 things NOT to say to a child with autism- -and what to say instead
of 21 things NOT to say to a person with an autism spectrum disorder, compiled with the help of members of my facebook autism forum:How golf can help students with Autism
New after-school youth sports program in Canada brings golf to students with AutismNews Actress Talks Playing Character with Autism on Award-Winning TV Show
Autism Speaks Staffer Kerry Magro interviewed actress Diane Kruger (National Treasure, Inglorious Basterds) who plays a character with Asperger Syndrome on the hit FX series “The Bridge.” You can tune into the season 2 premiere of "The Bridge" tonight at 10 PM ET/9 PM CT on FX!Why children with autism often fall victim to bullies
Bullying can affect anyone at any time, but young people with autism are especially vulnerable.A day in the life of a physics student with autism
Michael Barton, 22, has high-functioning autism and has just finished a degree course. He is currently promoting a new book - his second in three years, entitled A Different Kettle of Fish - A Day in the Life of a Physics Student with Autism.How to Teach an Autistic Child to Swim
Many parents and professionals want to know how to teach an autistic child to swim. Some children naturally love the water while others are very apprehensive.Tips for Keeping Autistic Spectrum Children Engaged During Summer Break
Tips for Keeping Autistic Spectrum Children Engaged During Summer BreakAutism policy changes should not worry parents, Blais says
Education minister says intervention appointments missed due to illness won't affect servicesWinterbourne View: One autistic boy's tragic tale
How one boy's moving story illustrates the tragedy of those still stuck in inappropriate care homes, despite Government promisesAutism is growing up
(CNN) -- As the world's leading autism researchers and advocates gathered at the International Meeting for Autism Research last weekend to share the latest discoveries about autism spectrum disorder, a strong theme emerged: Autism is growing upBrave Kid With Autism Confronts His Bullies In Front Of The Whole Class, Leaves Us Speechless
One of the hardest things to do to a bully is to confront them. Harder still is to do it without making the problem worse.Science News FDA Cracks Down on False Claims about Autism Treatments
Agency issues consumer warning; threatens legal action against those who market unproven, potentially dangerous products and therapiesNumber of Teens and Young Adults with Autism in College on the Rise Number of Teens and Young Adults with Autism in College on the Rise
(April 29, 2014) - A FOX outlet in Cleveland last week highlighted the growing number of teens and young adults with autism attending college.4 Qualities of People With Autism That Could Benefit Your Business
The Israeli Defense Force’s Satellite Intelligence Unit 9900 assigns autistic soldiers to monitor electronic combat maps for even the minutest changes. Their rare ability to focus for hours on end provides better results than non-autistic soldiersAutism within the British Asian community
Disability is a taboo in the Asian community; many prefer not to talk about issues affecting them or their families. But tackling these issues openly is essential. DESIblitz speak to a mother and daughter about their experiences with autism.Touching Video Explores Being a Dad to a Child with Autism
New media company SoulPancake produces a video series called The Fatherhood Project where filmmaker Corbyn Tyson explores what it means to be a good dad.Autism research isn’t helping people live with daily reality
In the summer of 2010 as England was being knocked out of the World Cup in South Africa, something all together more hopeful was happening in London.Athlete with Autism Adds Amazing Boston Marathon Finish to His ESPY
Jason "J-Mac" McElwain has a message for kids with autism: "It's amazing what you can accomplish when you put your mind to it."